Suppose a person has two esrogim, an inferior one that is definitely kosher and a beautiful one of questionable validity (it may have been from a grafted tree).

More on Sukkos

All of Sukkos Adding Schach for Warmth Beautiful Esrog of Questionable Validity Borrowing Someone Else's Lulav Building Your Own Sukkah Buying a Lulav With Shadchanus Money Children and the Mitzvah of Sukkah Clotheslines Over a Sukkah Display Model Sukkah Dofen Akumah Sukkah Eating an Esrog After Sukkos Elephant as a Sukkah Wall Forgot the Aravos in the Lulav Holding the Esrog Upside Down Holding the Four Minim Together Indoor Sukkah With a Retractable Roof Intent While Eating in the Sukkah Lavud Making a Sukkah Invalid Lulav All Seven Days of Sukkos Maximum Height of a Sukkah Minimum Sukkah Height Pesukim on Sukkah Decorations Picking Arba Minim in Eretz Yisrael Sleeping Outside the Sukkah Snow on the Sukkah Sukkah Decorations on Yom Tov Sukkah Walls Not Reaching the Schach Thick Schach Tying Down Schach With String Wooden Blinds as Schach

Choosing Between Two Esrogim – Sukkos in the Gemara | Daf Yomi Insights